90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? Season 9 Episode 5 Review: Are We Being Punked?

Does anyone else feel like we’re being punked with 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? Season 9?

Just when it seemed the franchise was inching toward a comeback, 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? Season 9 Episode 5 stumbles in wearing last year’s plotlines and smelling faintly of desperation.

The editors have somehow perfected the art of stretching ten minutes of story into two hours of television.

It’s like being served a charcuterie board where all the meat and cheese has been replaced with unsalted crackers.

Gino & Jasmine: The Never-Ending Shriekfest on 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After?

We start with Gino and Jasmine’s reunion, which began on a somewhat civil note and then quickly devolved into a screaming match that made me reach for the mute button.

There’s shouting, and then there’s whatever the hell that was — a shrill symphony of emotional warfare that could peel the paint off your walls.

Here’s the thing: Gino’s sudden “change of heart” about his marriage isn’t that sudden. It’s painfully clear he’s been mentally preparing to exit for a while, probably since the first time Jasmine side-eyed him for wearing that cursed hat indoors.

• The Gilded Age Season 3 Episode 7 Brings Gunshots, Ghostings, and Plenty of Gilded Delusions To Go Around
  by Whitney Evans
• 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? Season 9 Episode 5 Review: Are We Being Punked?
  by Paul Dailly
• Burn the Whole Damn Thing Down: The Institute Season 1 Episode 5 Reveals Its Nauseating Twist
  by Carissa Pavlica

He’s been marinating in suspicion about Matt long before agreeing to an open marriage, and yet somehow, he’s the victim? Sure, Jan.

The irony is rich. Jasmine has put up with Gino’s many fibs and half-truths, but the moment she’s accused of moving on, he’s practically on the phone with a divorce attorney.

And of course, instead of admitting his part in this disaster, Gino pulls out the ol’ gaslighting playbook until Jasmine is questioning her reality.

What’s truly shocking is that members of Gino’s own family are taking Jasmine’s side, essentially telling him to get a grip.

If your relatives are siding with the woman you’ve been accusing for months, maybe — just maybe — you’re the problem.

And now, with the bombshell that Matt is Jasmine’s baby daddy, this storyline has officially jumped from messy to Maury.

If Gino had even a flicker of interest in salvaging this marriage, that light just went out. Expect him to use this as a springboard to divorce and move on to his next doomed relationship.

Matt, meanwhile, actually listens to Jasmine, treats her well, and seems like he might be capable of existing without a fedora glued to his scalp.

• Why I’m Rooting for the “New Threats” After The Challenge Season 41 Premiere
  by Paul Dailly
• I’m Thrilled Al Calderon Will Be On Brilliant Minds, But Doubly Excited That Javi Isn’t Leaving Salem
  by Jack Ori
• When Late-Night Lost the Plot
  by Carissa Pavlica

I’d say she’s trading up. And if the chaos promised in the 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? Season 9 trailer is any indication, the upcoming party where Jasmine and Natalie are in the same room will be the reality TV equivalent of a car crash you can’t look away from.

But seriously, why are two grown women fighting over Gino? I wouldn’t wish that fate on my worst enemy.

Darcey & Georgi: Sex Noises for the Camera

Speaking of things no one asked for, Darcey decided it would be cute to make exaggerated sex noises loud enough for Georgi to hear from outside the room.

It wasn’t sexy. It wasn’t flirty. It was pure secondhand embarrassment.

Look, honeymoon suites have reputations. Everyone knows what they’re for. But Darcey made sure the entire hotel knew, just in case the soundproofing was decent.

It’s the kind of stunt you pull when you’re painfully aware your storyline is circling the drain and you’re desperately trying to cling to screen time.

The sad part is there’s nothing left to explore here. This isn’t a relationship arc anymore; it’s two people killing time between paid brand trips.

TLC and Sharp Entertainment need to be far pickier about which alums they recycle, because not every familiar face has another season of story to tell.

No amount of editing wizardry can turn this storyline into something watchable. It’s a filler package in human form.

Brandon & Julia: The Unexpected MVPs

And then we have Brandon and Julia, who somehow — against all odds — have become the most compelling couple of the season.

Maybe it’s because their issues actually feel rooted in reality instead of producer-manufactured chaos.

Julia’s still battling with Brandon’s parents’ constant interference and his tendency to sit silently while she takes the heat, but their current focus — whether to have kids — has actual stakes.

• 5 Things Murder in a Small Town Needs to Fix in Season 2
  by Laura Nowak
• The Hunting Wives Cast: Where Have You Seen Them Before?
  by Carissa Pavlica
• Creepy Kids’ TV: 13 Classic Live-Action Shows That Gave Us Goosebumps (and Eerie Vibes)
  by Carissa Pavlica

You can see the weight of it on both of them, and it’s miles more engaging than watching someone rehearse a screaming match for the cameras.

Julia’s journey this season feels authentic. She’s wrestling with her own hesitations about motherhood while trying to navigate a marriage where her in-laws are practically a third partner.

Brandon, bless his heart, still needs to learn how to be a united front with his wife, but at least they’re dealing with real-life questions instead of manufactured brawls over who texted who.

They’re not perfect — far from it — but their dynamic has genuine emotional beats that make me want to keep watching. That’s rare on a season where half the cast seems to be phoning it in.

Two Hours, Zero Payoff

The biggest problem with 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? right now is that it’s forgotten how to balance drama with progress.

We’re getting endless loops of the same fights, recycled confessionals, and irrelevant filler scenes that serve no purpose beyond inflating runtime.

It’s almost insulting that producers think they can keep tossing two-hour episodes at us without actually moving the story forward.

Reality TV works when it feels messy and meaningful. Right now, it’s just messy — and not in the fun way.

At this point, I’m not sure if TLC’s keeping all this pointless footage because they think fans want it, or because they have nothing else to air. Either way, it’s becoming a chore to sit through.

If the back half of the season doesn’t bring something fresh — and soon — this could go down as one of the franchise’s weakest installments yet. And that’s saying something.

So, what do you think? Are you as over the repetitive scenes and manufactured drama as I am?

Or are you somehow still invested in watching these couples hash out the same fights week after week? Sound off in the comments — preferably with less screeching than Gino and Jasmine.

Hit the comments.

Watch 90 Day Fiance: Happily Ever After? Online

TV Fanatic is searching for passionate contributors to share their voices across various article types. Think you have what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click here for more information and next steps.

The post 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? Season 9 Episode 5 Review: Are We Being Punked? appeared first on TV Fanatic.