Sailorr – ‘From Florida’s Finest’ review: a pop-ified debut that overshares with style

May 9, 2025 - 09:14

0 0

Sailorr

Sailorr loves love. Whether she’s a certified horndog spilling her filthiest fantasies, mourning past relationships (before promptly roasting useless men into oblivion) or riding high on platonic escapades, Florida’s newest R&B rebel has always made romance of all kinds her muse. So it’s no surprise that her hotly anticipated debut mixtape ‘From Florida’s Finest’ showcases just that – and then some. It’s not just a love letter to the chaos of relationships but also her step into the glossy realm of pop instead of the alt-R&B lane many boxed her into after her brooding breakout single ‘Pookie’s Requiem’, which had TikTok wrapped around her perfectly manicured finger and racked up tens of millions of streams.

READ MORE: R&B’s new rebel Sailorr: “I never wanted my music to be too serious. I just want people to connect”

‘Pookie’s Requiem’ was the perfect teaser for what’s in store on ‘From Florida’s Finest’: all the smouldering synths and tear-streaked melodrama offset by gut-punch humour introduced Sailorr’s signature blend of drama and detail without ever cheapening either. It tracks, then, that ‘Ur Mother’s Son’ – its spiritual sequel – swaps out the gloom for lofty acoustic strums and faint, searing violins as she confronts the heartache of loving a mummy’s boy. If there’s one track that cements her rep as a lyrical heavyweight, it’s this one. She spirals into self-doubt (“Keeping up the lies, wasn’t that good enough? / Couldn’t meet your mum ‘cause I ain’t good enough?”) but then she gets herself together, hiding behind her sharp tongue: “Hold, hold tight to your mum / You, son of a bitch.”

That ability to cry one moment and crack up the next defines ‘From Florida’s Finest’. Between emotional verses and tender melodies, Sailorr peppers the tape with unhinged skits that feel lifted from her camera roll. There’s the snot-nosed outro on ‘Pookie’s Requiem’, her hyping up a friend’s freestyle on ‘MSG’, and trying to wrangle her delusional “male-centred” friend after she hits the curb on ‘Gimme Dat Lug Nut’. These aren’t throwaway moments – they’re windows into her world, blurring the line between heartbreak and voicemail, pop and parody.

She blurs the lines well. ‘Down Bad’ and ‘Grrl’s Grrl’ are moreish servings of fluttery vocals, trampoline-like 808s and comedic storytelling. But ‘Done Shaving 4 U’ and ‘Itadakimasu’ are the funniest tracks on the mixtape. The former calls out all the “bums” who’ve played with Sailorr’s heart, delivering an earnest track about cutting ties with a man who can’t make an effort, all wrapped in a signature Sailorr-ism: “Couldn’t get me no drink from the corner store / On the bed, no frame, straight on the floor / Boy, you a waste, so I ain’t shaving my legs for you no more.”

Meanwhile, ‘Itadakimasu’ sparkles with twinkling chimes and lush organ chords, evoking a nostalgic 2010s minimalism found in Tumblr-era hits. Lyrically, it’s one of her funniest, commanding a potential suitor to “come bless this (meow) for you” and joking, “I like my men soft-spoken, but real loud with their pockets.” That cheek, paired with her silky tones, places her squarely in the orbit of SZA, Doja Cat, and Summer Walker – and on ‘From Florida’s Finest’, she belongs right alongside them.

However, that comparison doesn’t always work in her favour. ‘Cut Up’ – although a sultry and soulful toxic tale of unrequited love – does feel like a watered-down version of a SZA song. ‘Bitches Brew’ is twinkly and slick while dripping with baddie energy, but its overly glitzy production and sugar-coated chorus veer dangerously close to ‘Planet Her’-era Doja Cat. Although the ethos of letting chaos boil and getting your lick back works well in theory, the song’s syrupy, subdued style weakens her usual bite and stops it from becoming the empowering anthem it could be.

When Sailorr doesn’t compromise her artistry, she strikes gold. Yes, she sometimes slips unknowingly into repetitive pop formulas, but her headstrong flair and inimitable pen game elevate her beyond just another viral sensation. She’s not quite gunning for a spot next to Doja, SZA or Summer Walker, but she’s circling the same orbit, carving out a lane with just as much attitude. ‘From Florida’s Finest’ is more than an introduction – it’s a love-soaked, meme-sprinkled dispatch from the generation of oversharers.